This phrase refers to a specific type of true crime or domestic suspense narrative centered around seemingly ordinary suburban families harboring dark secrets. Often, the narrative unfolds from the perspective of neighbors or those within the community, highlighting the unsettling contrast between outward appearances and hidden realities. A typical example might involve a seemingly perfect family grappling with addiction, infidelity, or even criminal activity, unbeknownst to their close-knit community.
These narratives resonate with audiences due to their exploration of universal themes like deception, betrayal, and the fragility of social structures. By placing these themes within the familiar context of suburban life, such stories tap into anxieties about the unknown lurking beneath the surface of seemingly idyllic communities. The popularity of this subgenre reflects a broader cultural fascination with true crime and the desire to understand the motivations behind seemingly inexplicable acts of violence or deviance.